ArcaMax

Butcher block has long been a hard-working surface for cabinet countertops, table tops and work surfaces, but when it becomes scratched, stained and scarred it can be an eyesore. However, it’s a forgiving material that can be restored with a process of basic scraping, sanding and finishing to restore the surface to like-new condition.

A handyman will charge $225, including labor and material, to restore a 4-foot-long butcher block surface. With a minimum of tools and talents, a handy homeowner can do the job for $30, the cost of the materials, and save 87%.

The job involves several steps that build on each other, starting with clearing the surface and masking the surrounding surface to protect it. Then you use a wood or paint scraper to lightly shave off the top layer of blemishes. Treat any dark stains or blotches with a mixture of half bleach and water or wood bleach following the manufacturer’s directions. More than one application may be needed. Use a palm sander with several grades of sandpaper to remove scratches and stains until the surface is blemish-free. Minwax Tung Oil Finish and Watco Butcher Block Finish are two good choices following the manufacturer’s directions.

Pro Cost: $225 — DIY Cost: $30 — Pro time: 0.7
DIY Time: 1.5 — DIY Savings: $195 — Percent Saved: 87%

========

To find more DIY project costs and to post comments and questions, visit www.diyornot.com and m.diyornot.com on smartphones.

©2026 Gene and Katie Hamilton. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.